District of Columbia Court of Appeals July 7, 1981, 79-945 (Owens v. Curtis)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-07-1981

MACK, Associate Judge:

Appellant, the purchaser of certain real estate, filed suit against the seller, the realty company and the real estate agent involved in the sale. Following a nonjury trial, a motion to dismiss was granted with respect to the realty company and judgment was entered in favor of the seller and the agent. Appeal is brought only with respect to the judgment in favor of the seller. We affirm.

In March 1978 the appellant, a prospective home buyer, examined residential property owned by the appellee. During the 30 minute inspection appellant noted signs of deterioration on the walls of a basement closet. She inquired whether the deterioration was the result of fire or water damage. Appellee answered that she did not know the cause of the damage and that the deterioration existed when she moved in a few years ago. When asked about tiles missing from the basement floor, appellee responded that the tiles were old and old tiles come up. Following this inspection a sales contract was entered into.

Appellant sought to further inspect the house on a rainy day but the appellee suggested an alternate date. On another occasion, appellant briefly visited the property to check the size of rooms and location of windows and to consider remodeling the kitchen.

Appellant intended to have a friend with some experience in real estate accompany her on a presettlement inspection. Had the friend noticed defects, appellant planned to demand either repair of the defects or an appropriate adjustment in price. However, following scheduling difficulties, the agent handling the sale informed appellant that she would have to inspect the premises immediately or forfeit her presettlement inspection. Appellant, unable to reach her friend, made the inspection alone. After settlement she discovered that the deterioration in the closet and the missing tiles were the result of a flooding problem in the basement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.