District Court, D. Montana March 6, 1981, CV-79-50-Bu (Stillwater Condominium Ass'n v. American Home Assurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-03-1981

MEMORANDUM and ORDER

WILLIAM D. MURRAY, Senior District Judge.

This diversity action is for declaratory judgment to determine the rights of the parties under a comprehensive general liability (CGL) insurance policy and an umbrella liability policy. Land developer Big Sky of Montana, Inc. (Big Sky), purchased the CGL policy from American Home Assurance Company (American Home) and the umbrella liability policy from Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company. The damages

*1077

which plaintiff contends are covered by the liability policies arise out of a civil action in a Montana district court (the

Stillwater

action).

The facts of the

Stillwater

action are as follows. Big Sky built and marketed the Stillwater condominiums in the highly scenic Big Sky Resort area. The purchasers of the condominiums, as the Stillwater Condominium Association, brought suit against Big Sky to recover damages for faulty workmanship because the condominiums were poorly constructed. Just a few of the indicia of that poor construction were leaking roofs, delaminating siding, and improperly installed wiring and plumbing.

Big Sky tendered defense of the

Stillwater

action to American Home. American Home refused to defend, contending that a CGL policy does not provide coverage for the allegations of the

Stillwater

action. That action ultimately settled, and the Still-water Condominium Association acquired through that settlement “[a]ll rights, title, and interest in any and all insurance policies procured by Big Sky of Montana, Inc., which would or could provide insurance coverage for the damages alleged.... ” This court must determine whether the liability policies here at issue provide coverage for the occurrences of the

Stillwater

action, and more particularly, whether American Home had a duty to defend.

In the

Stillwater

action the Stillwater Condominium Association alleged breach of express warranty, breach of implied warranty, breach of contract, strict liability in tort, and negligence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.