District Court, D. South Carolina December 2, 1981, Civ. A. 80-1108-14 (Eastern Federal Corp. v. Wasson)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-12-1981

ORDER

WILKINS, District Judge.

In this civil rights action, Plaintiff challenges the constitutionality of South Carolina Code Section 12-21-2710. This statute imposes a 20% tax on “X” rated and non-rated movies,

1

while South Carolina Code Section 12-21-2420 imposes a 4% tax on movies rated by the Motion Picture Association of America. Plaintiff has sued under the provisions of Title 42, United States Code Section 1983 and Title 28, United States Code Section 1343(3) seeking declaratory and injunctive relief.

FINDINGS OF FACT

Prior to trial the parties entered into a stipulation of facts. After reviewing this agreement, I have adopted those facts which are material to this Order.

Plaintiff owns and operates a movie theater in Columbia, South Carolina which shows “X” rated and non-rated movies. As a result, South Carolina law charges it with the responsibility of collecting the 20% admissions tax from its patrons. All movie houses showing movies rated by the Motion Picture Association of America (“G”, “PG” and “R”) are required to collect a 4% admissions tax. Plaintiff has complied with the law for the last several years and presently is not delinquent in its payment of the tax. Defendants are employees of the South Carolina Tax Commission who are charged with enforcing South Carolina’s tax laws. They are unaware of any pending criminal prosecutions against Plaintiff for failure to comply with the statute.

*243

DISCUSSION

Although this case was brought under the Federal Civil Rights Statute, the threshold issue is whether this court has subject matter jurisdiction. The mere assertion of a federal claim is not sufficient to trigger the jurisdiction of this court. Federal jurisdiction is created by statute and, therefore, exists only where Congress has provided it.

Turner v. Bank of North America,

4 U.S. (4 Dall.) 7, 11, 1 L.Ed. 718 (1799). The Constitution does not require Congress to provide a federal forum for the vindication of every federal right.

See Sheldon v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.