Supreme Court of Alabama February 27, 1981, 79-659 (Campbell v. Carl)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-02-1981

This is a suit in equity to establish a boundary line between two parcels of land. The plaintiff's husband, Maynard Carl, originally owned both parcels of land and later conveyed them and other contiguous property to the plaintiff, Raeder Carl, on August 21, 1946. This deed described the southern and northern parcels as the SW 1/4 and NW 1/4, respectively, of the SW 1/4, Section 5, Township 9 North, Range 1 West. Each parcel contained about 40 acres of farm land. On January 15, 1949, Raeder Carl conveyed the southern parcel and the other contiguous property by deed to S.J. Smith, retaining for herself the northern parcel. This deed contained the following description of the conveyed property (emphasized portions apply to the boundaries of the southern parcel): Southwest Quarter of the Southwest Quarter of Section 5, Township 9, North, Range One West; Ten (10) acres in the Northeast Quarter of Northwest Quarter of Northwest Quarter of Section 8, Township 9 North, Range one West. Also ten (10) acres in the Northwest corner of the Northwest Quarter of Section 8, Township 9 North, Range One West; Containing in all sixty (60) acres, more or less. Agreement is that a road be left open from Maynard Carl's Barn to Mack York's field gate. Road at this time being the line. Smith and the Carls lived in harmony as neighbors until Smith's death on September 12, 1975. Smith's property passed by intestacy to his widow, Minnie Smith Campbell, and heirs at law. The widow and heirs ordered a survey of the property and hacked a line on the boundary determined by the survey. This line placed the Carls' old barn on the property of Smith's widow and heirs and apparently ran through the Carls' new barn. Disputing this surveyed line as the true boundary between the two parcels of land, Raeder Carl filed this suit against Smith's widow and heirs. Evidence was taken ore tenus without a jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.