Louisiana Court of Appeal September 29, 1981, 12308 (Hebert v. Cournoyer Oldsmobile-Cadillac-GMC, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-09-1981
405 So.2d 359 (1981) Raymond J. HEBERT v. COURNOYER OLDSMOBILE-CADILLAC-GMC, INC. et al. No. 12308. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit. September 29, 1981. Rehearings Denied November 9, 1981. *360 Gordon Hackman, Boutte, for plaintiff-appellant. Sessions, Fishman, Rosenson, Boisfontaine & Nathan, Jack M. Alltmont, New Orleans, for Cournoyer Oldsmobile-Cadillac-GMC, Inc. Bernard, Cassisa, Babst & Saporito, Stephen N. Elliott, Metairie, for General Motors Corp. Before REDMANN, SCHOTT and KLEES, JJ. REDMANN, Judge. Plaintiff appeals from the dismissal of his damage action on exception of prescription. The question is whether under La.C.C. 3519 the interruption of prescription by an earlier lawsuit "is considered as never having happened" when the judgment dismissing the earlier suit "without prejudice" (a few days before this suit was filed) is prefaced "after hearing ... stipulation by and between counsel ...," indicating a stipulation for a dismissal without prejudice, and the transcript shows "a joint motion of all counsel... to dismiss ... without prejudice." The impasse at which plaintiff had arrived in the original suit was that, apparently through his own counsel's fault in not properly responding to discovery regarding expert witnesses, the trial judge would not allow plaintiff's expert to testify (in a case of a new automobile's self-igniting, burning itself and plaintiff's house as well). Had defense counsel opposed the motion for dismissal "without prejudice," plaintiff might have obtained review, by writ or post-trial appeal, of the trial judge's ruling on the expert (and might even have won the case on a res ipsa theory without the expert). Instead, defense counsel joined in the motion to dismiss "without prejudice" and ought not now to be heard to insist that the dismissal was with prejudiceprejudice to the point of extinction of plaintiff's claim by prescription. Our case is therefore distinguished from Adams v. Aetna Cas. & S. Co., 214 So.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit