Missouri Court of Appeals September 15, 1981, 42637 (McIntosh v. Dowdy)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1981

REINHARD, Judge.

Plaintiffs appeal from an adverse judgment in an action to cancel a deed for fraud, undue influence, and lack of mental capacity. On appeal, plaintiffs contend that the court’s judgment was against the weight of the evidence. We disagree, however, and hence we affirm.

Our review of court-tried cases is governed by the standards set out in

Murphy v. Carron,

536 S.W.2d 30 (Mo.banc 1976): “(T)he decree or judgment of the trial court will be sustained by the appellate court unless there is no substantial evidence to support it, unless it is against the weight of the evidence, unless it erroneously declares the law, or unless it erroneously applies the law.”

Id.

at 32.

Lucie Sonia Burch, plaintiffs’ decedent, executed the deed in question on August 26, 1978. It conveyed her house to defendants reserving for her a life estate. Plaintiffs are Dennis McIntosh, Administrator of Mrs. Burch’s estate, Sterling C. Burch, Mrs. Burch’s husband, and Marcel Quesnell, Mrs. Burch’s brother. Mr. Burch and Mr. Ques-nell are Mrs. Burch’s sole devisees and legatees under her will.

Mrs. Burch was 78 years old in July of 1978 when she fractured her hip and was hospitalized. She spent several weeks in the hospital. Her doctor recommended that, after her release from the hospital, she receive care during her recovery. Because Mr. Burch, who lived at the Burch house, was unable to care for her, a patient representative at the hospital helped to place Mrs. Burch in defendants’ boarding home.

While at defendants’ boarding home, Mrs. Burch was unable to walk or clothe herself, but she was able to feed herself. She required daily insulin shots and a diabetic diet. Defendants charged $300 per month. Mrs. Burch had income of roughly $120 per month. The evidence indicates Mrs. Burch was only able to pay $100 the first month. Defendants had the deed to Mrs. Burch’s house drawn up to secure payment for their services, and in exchange agreed to care for Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.