United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Massachusetts September 28, 1981, 19-10390 (Fruehauf Corp. v. Sherman (In Re Gringeri Bros. Transportation Co.))
Also known as
United States · · · 28-09-1981
MEMORANDUM ON COMPLAINT TO RECLAIM MOTOR VEHICLES
THOMAS W. LAWLESS, Bankruptcy Judge.
The Court has before it a complaint filed by the plaintiff, Fruehauf Corporation (“Fruehauf”) to reclaim from the estate of the bankrupt, Gringeri Bros. Transportation Co., Inc. (the “bankrupt”) twelve motor vehicles in which Fruehauf alleges to have valid and perfected security interests. The defendant, the trustee in bankruptcy (the “trustee”), contests Fruehauf’s claim that its security interests are perfected and opposes the claim for reclamation. Subsequent to the filing of the complaint and upon agreement of the parties, the Court ordered that the motor vehicles be sold with liens to attach to the proceeds of the sale. Thus the issue is the priority between Frue-hauf and the trustee with regard to the proceeds generated from the sale of the motor vehicles.
A trial was held on Fruehauf’s complaint. Based upon the testimony and the documents received into evidence, I find the facts to be as set forth below.
From April 26,1977 through May 4,1978, Fruehauf entered into seven separate retail installment contracts for the sale of motor vehicles (trailers) to Newton Truck Rental, Inc. (“Newton”).
1
These installment contracts involved a total of twelve motor vehicles including four new and eight used trailers.
In order to better understand the overall transactions between Fruehauf and New
*398
ton, it is necessary, at least briefly, to review the circumstances involved in each of the contracts.
The first five of the used trailers sold to Newton (the subjects of the installment contracts of April 26 and June 27,1977) had previously been sold by Fruehauf to Delaware Equipment Inc. (“Delaware”), a corporation doing business in Maine. Those trailers were then registered in Maine and Maine certificates of title were obtained showing Delaware as the owner and Frue-hauf as the first lienholder.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit