United States Bankruptcy Court, W.D. Virginia January 14, 1981, 19-50094 (Brown v. Frank Meador Buick, Inc. (In Re Frank Meador Buick, Inc.))

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-1981

MEMORANDUM OPINION

H. CLYDE PEARSON, Bankruptcy Judge.

The issue before the Court involves the right of the Plaintiff to a trial by jury upon the issues framed in the Complaint filed herein.

Frank Meador Buick, Inc., a Buick automobile dealership in Roanoke, Virginia, is a Chapter 11 Debtor in this Court. In the acquisition of the dealership, Frank Meador, Jr. contracted with Lewis 0. Brown, Jr., Plaintiff, to purchase the dealership. The contract of these parties, its interpretation, meaning and financial compensation due thereunder is in issue in this adversary proceeding.

The Defendant contends that the contract is executory and defendant desires to reject the same; that as such the Debtor’s liability may be limited so far as future compensation to the Plaintiff under the terms of the contract is concerned. The Plaintiff contends the contract is not execu-tory but is a complete contract, the rights of the Debtor to be compensated under its terms, are the only matters in issue for resolution by this Court.

Plaintiff has requested a trial by jury on the issues surrounding the meaning and construction of the contract; that if the case were at issue in a State or Federal Court a right to trial by jury would clearly exist and the Plaintiff would have full right thereto. The Defendant contends that the rights of the Plaintiff amounts to a claim against the Chapter 11 Debtor in these proceedings and as such, historically under the

Bankruptcy Act of 1898

which vested in this Court only summary jurisdiction the Plaintiff is not entitled to trial by jury.

For the reasons hereafter, the Court is of the opinion that a right of trial by jury exists.

Counsel for the Defendant, in support of Defendant’s objection to the granting of a jury trial filed in support thereof a memorandum of authorities. The numerous authorities cited deal with cases construing the

Bankruptcy Act of 1898,

the final construction of which generally was rendered in the case of

Katchen v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.