Appellate Court of Illinois February 17, 1981, 80-574 (People v. Bochniak)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-02-1981

Mr. JUSTICE McGLOON

delivered the opinion of the court;

This is an appeal by the State, pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 604(a)(1), from an order by the trial court sustaining defendant’s motion to suppress.

After he received a tip-off that defendant Robert Bochniak and his brother had stolen materials from defendant’s place of employment, Officer Stasinopoulos went to 2554 West Augusta in Chicago, believing that to be defendant’s home address. Defendant actually resided at 2550 West Augusta. When the officer knocked on the door at 2554 West Augusta, defendant’s mother, Mrs. Catherine Olijnek answered.

When the officer informed Mrs. Olijnek that there were stolen goods in the garage, she claimed that it was untrue but invited him to inspect. The officer testified that Mrs. Olijnek and defendant’s brother Michael entered the garage and that he followed. Mrs. Olijnek testified that she did not accompany the officer to the garage. It is undisputed, however, that the door was opened with her key. Inside the garage, the officer found electrical supplies.

Defendant arrived at his mother’s home and asked the police what they were doing in the garage. The officer informed him that he was looking for stolen electrical supplies and that he did not need a search warrant because the landlord had granted him entry.

Mrs. Olijnek was the owner of the garage, but had been renting it out to her two sons for $20 per month for approximately 6 years. She testified that she never used the garage.

The trial court sustained defendant’s motion to suppress the evidence. The State appeals from that order.

We affirm.

On appeal, the State argues that the trial court erred in sustaining defendant’s motion to suppress because (1) defendant’s mother had the actual authority to consent to a search of the garage, or (2) defendant’s mother had the apparent authority to consent to a search of the garage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.