California Court of Appeal March 27, 1981, Crim. 20187 (People v. Pangelina)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-03-1981

Opinion

NEWSOM, J.

The present appeal arises under the following circumstances.

An indictment returned by the Santa Clara Grand Jury on August 30, 1978, charged appellants and four named codefendants with conspiracy (Pen. Code, § 182) to keep a house of prostitution (Pen. Code, § 315). On September 13, 1978, appellants were arraigned, entered a plea of not guilty, and waived time; they did not, however, join with their codefendants in expressly reserving the right to demur.

On October 16, 1978, codefendant Gloria Washington made various pretrial motions, including motions for a postindictment preliminary

*417

hearing and to suppress, in which she was subsequently joined by appellants. On January 22, 1979, defendants’ motions to set aside the plea and for a postindictment preliminary hearing were argued and submitted.

1

The court denied the motions, reserving defendants’ rights to withdraw the pleas for the purpose of demurring.

A subsequent hearing on the same motions was held on February 2, 1979. The motion to suppress was continued at defense counsel’s request. In a memorandum decision filed February 8, 1979, the motion for a postindictment preliminary hearing and to withdraw pleas was granted as to all defendants except appellants, who had failed to “reserve a demurrer” at the time of entering their plea.

Following this ruling, on March 7 and 13, 1979, appellants Leah Pangelina and Debra Ann Frazier, respectively! withdrew their previously entered time-waivers and demanded a trial within the statutory time. A trial was set and on March 20, 1979, various pretrial motions (none of which involved suppression of evidence), were unsuccessfully, made and jury selection commenced. Subsequently appellants informed the court of a request for a ruling on a motion to suppress, and the court “reserved jurisdiction” to rule.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.