South Dakota Supreme Court August 26, 1981, 13040 (Roth v. Pier)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-08-1981

PER CURIAM.

In this appeal the trial court concluded that the funds remaining in a joint checking account in the names of Theodor Roth (decedent), Clarence Roth (appellant), and John Roth were an asset of decedent’s estate. We affirm.

In 1975, after decedent’s wife died, John Roth’s name was placed on decedent and Katie Roth’s checking account. Shortly thereafter, decedent became extremely ill and moved to a nursing home. Appellant assumed the responsibility for decedent’s business affairs and, after June 14, 1978, signed all but one of the checks written on decedent and John Roth’s account.

On August 12, 1978, appellant procured a signature card from the bank for the “joint and several account payable to either or survivor,” checking account. He returned the card to the bank with his signature and the signatures of decedent and John Roth. Decedent, who could neither read nor write anything other than his name, did not give written or oral notification to the bank of any intention to change the ownership of the account.

Throughout the history of the checking account, the funds were used to pay decedent’s bills. Neither appellant or John Roth ever deposited their money in the account. When decedent died, $9,262.49 remained in the account.

John Roth does not claim ownership of one-half of the balance remaining in the checking account as a surviving joint tenant; rather, he claims only that share that he will be entitled to as a residual heir of decedent. Appellant, however, argues that decedent clearly intended to transfer the balance of the account to the two survivors upon his death and that appellant, and not the estate, is entitled to one-half of the balance.

In

Barbour v. First Citizens National Bank of Watertown,

77 S.D. 106, 86 N.W.2d 526 (1957), we noted that the controlling consideration is the intention of the original depositor.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.