Appellate Court of Illinois June 11, 1981, 80-1684 (Kalalinick v. Knoll)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1981

Mr. PRESIDING JUSTICE ROMITI

delivered the opinion of the court:

The plaintiff filed suit against Harry Knoll for negligence and against his insurance carrier Country Mutual Insurance Company and its agent Townsend on an alleged settlement agreement. The suit in contract was voluntarily dismissed by the plaintiff, then reinstated. At trial on the contract claim, the trial court found there had been a settlement agreement, awarded judgment for the amount of the agreement plus prejudgment interest against both the insurer and its agent. Both appealed contending:

1. the court had no jurisdiction to reinstate the complaint once it had been voluntarily dismissed;

2. the agent Townsend cannot be personally liable on the contract;

3. the court erred in introducing into evidence a memorandum letter of the insurer which indicated that a settlement offer had in fact been made;

4. that the findings and judgment were against the manifest weight of the evidence;

5. that it was error to award prejudgment interest.

We agree with Townsend that, since the insurer for purposes of appeal has admitted that it is bound by any agreement made, the agent cannot be held liable on the agreement. Accordingly we reverse the judgment against the agent. We also agree with the insurer that the court erred in awarding prejudgment interest. We hold, however, that the court did not err in reinstating the complaint, in considering the memorandum letter or in finding that there was a binding settlement agreement. Accordingly we modify the judgment against the insurer to delete the award of prejudgment interest and affirm as modified.

I

Obviously the first question which must be addressed by this court is whether the trial court had the power to reinstate the complaint since if it did not have the power to do so, the case must be reversed and dismissed.

Suit was filed by the plaintiff against the three defendants on May 26, 1975.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.