Tennessee Supreme Court December 28, 1981 (State v. Butler)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-12-1981
OPINION
COOPER, Justice.
William Robert Butler was convicted of second degree murder and received a twenty year sentence, for shooting and killing his wife. He also was convicted of assault and battery for wounding a bystander in the same incident. On appeal of the murder conviction, the Court of Criminal Appeals concluded that the trial court committed prejudicial error (1) in ordering defense counsel to refrain from questioning juvenile prosecution witnesses about past juvenile court adjudications, and (2) in excluding evidence of threats by the deceased against the defendant, uncommunicated to him, which were tendered to show the state of mind of the deceased, and reversed the conviction. We granted the state’s application for permission to appeal to review the action of the Court of Criminal Appeals. At issue also is the denial by the trial court of an amendment to Butler’s motion for new trial.
The homicide victim was Mary Ellen Butler, the appellant’s estranged wife. Mrs. Butler and her three children shared a mobile home with her sister-in-law, Cathy Overton, and Cathy Overton’s son. Charles Lee Kirk, who was stationed at Millington Naval Air Station, spent the weekends at the trailer with Mrs. Butler. All of these parties and Jimmy Dale Perry, the teenage son of a neighbor, were present when Butler shot his wife.
The homicide occurred on the afternoon of February 15, 1979. Butler went to the trailer park where his wife lived, picked up two of her children and took them to a nearby store for a coca cola. When he brought the children home, Mrs. Butler went to the car and told Mr. Butler to stay away from her and the boys. Mrs. Butler and the children then walked toward the trailer. Mr. Butler called to his wife and asked her to come back to the car, that he wanted to talk with her. She told him that she did not have anything to say to him; however, when she reached the trailer door, she turned and started back toward the automobile. Just as Mrs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit