Court of Appeals of Texas May 22, 1981, 20450 (Vaughn Building Corp. v. Austin Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-05-1981

GUITTARD, Chief Justice.

Vaughn Building Corporation sued The Austin Company for breach of express and implied warranties in a contract to construct a commercial building. The breach of express warranty alleged was Austin’s failure to repair the roof after written notice, and the breach of implied warranty alleged was the unfitness of the roof for its particular purpose in that it failed to prevent water and the elements from coming inside the building. The trial court disregarded jury findings favorable to Vaughn and rendered judgment denying recovery. We hold that the verdict is supported by the evidence and that it is sufficient to support a judgment for breach of implied warranty. We also hold that the suit is not barred by limitation because Vaughn was effectively made a party plaintiff within four years after the date that the jury found an ordinary prudent person should have discovered that the roof was defective. Accordingly, we reverse and render judgment for Vaughn on the verdict without deciding whether Vaughn is entitled to recovery for breach of the express warranty.

*680

1.

Exclusion of Implied Warranty by Express Warranty

Austin seeks to support the judgment on the ground that the express warranty in the contract is exclusive and that the suit was not brought within four years after Vaughn’s cause of action for breach of the express warranty arose. The contract provides for a roof of “aggregate surfaced built-up asphalt water-proofing installed in accordance with the manufacturer’s specifications for a 20-year bondable type roof.”

Austin contends that the intentions of the parties to exclude any implied warranty is shown by the specification of a “20-bonda-ble type roof” and by evidence that Vaughn chose not to pay the premium for a bond to insure the roof. Austin also cites

Watel v. Richman, 576

S.W.2d 779 (Tex.1978), in which the supreme court declined to approve the holding in

Richman v. Watel,

565 S.W.2d 101, 102 (Tex.Civ.App.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.