Court of Appeals of Arizona February 19, 1981, 2 CA-CIV 3743 (Brumbaugh v. Pet Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-02-1981

OPINION

HOWARD, Judge.

This appeal arises from the entry of summary judgment in favor of appellee, Pet Corporation, and against appellant, Sandra Brumbaugh.

The facts necessary for a determination of this case are as follows. Paul Brumbaugh, appellant’s minor son, was killed in an automobile accident in which his father, William Brumbaugh, was driving. At the time of the accident, William was engaged in activities within the scope of his employment for appellee, Pet. Appellant, as the surviving natural mother of Paul, sued appellee on behalf of herself based solely on the negligence of its employee, her husband, William. In granting appellee’s motion for summary judgment, the court determined that appellee could not be held liable “solely on the derivative negligence of its employee, William Brumbaugh.” We reverse.

Appellant raises two issues for our consideration on appeal. First, that appellee is a proper defendant and that it cannot benefit from the immunity granted its agent under the doctrine of interspousal immunity and second, that any recovery from appellee would be appellant’s personal and separate property.

The question of whether an employer can claim immunity from suit when its negligent agent possesses immunity is one of first impression in Arizona. Absent authority to the contrary, Arizona will follow the Restatement position which, in this case, supports appellant’s claim.

Barnum

v.

Rural Fire Protection Company,

24 Ariz.App. 233, 537 P.2d 618 (1975).

The rule that the principal cannot assert immunities personal to its agent is found in the Restatement (Second) Agency Sec. 217(b), pp. 468-69 which provides:

“In an action against a principal based on the conduct of a servant in the course of employment:

******

(b) The principal has no defense because of the fact that:

(i) he had a non-delegable privilege to do the act,, or

(ii) the agent had an immunity from civil liability as to the act.”

Comment

b

further illustrates the point:

“b. Immunities.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.