Utah Supreme Court February 10, 1981, 16873 (Thurman v. Byram)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-02-1981

HOWE, Justice:

Appeal from a judgment that a 10-mile road passing through defendants’ land had become a public road and that a prescriptive easement had been established in favor of the plaintiffs.

Defendants are the owners of real property located in Cottonwood Canyon in Morgan County. Plaintiffs sought a determination that the road coursing through defendants’ land had been used by the general public for a period in excess of 10 years prior to defendants’ installation of a gate blocking the road in 1978, and that the road had thus become a public road. The statutory basis for plaintiffs’ claim is § 27-12-89, U.C.A.1953, as amended, which provides:

A highway shall be deemed to have been dedicated and abandoned to the use of the public when it has been continuously used as a public thoroughfare for a period of 10 years.

The trial court found there had been the requisite use.

Defendants contend that the trial court committed prejudicial error in making Findings of Fact which were contrary to the evidence, and that the evidence does not support the judgment.

As to defendants’ complaint that some of the court’s Findings of Fact were based on erroneous interpretations of the testimony, we find no prejudicial error. Although defendants have pointed out certain discrepancies, for the most part they have simply relied on testimony that supported their position but which was in conflict with other testimony found believable by the trial court. Even if the challenged findings were stricken, the remaining findings are based on credible testimony and amply support the judgment.

Defendants’ challenge based on insufficiency of the evidence is likewise without merit. Although dedication of property to public use should not be lightly presumed, the determination of the facts establishing the requisite public use is the primary responsibility of the trial court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.