Supreme Court of Oklahoma April 20, 1981, 52417 (Catlin Aviation Co. v. Equilease Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-04-1981

DOOLIN, Justice:

Equilease (seller) sold to Catlin (buyer) an aircraft for $130,000.00. The bill of sale, dated June 19, 1974 contained a warranty of title. Seller also gave buyer a “hold harmless” letter which stated, “we will agree to hold you harmless to any claim in the event any suit is instituted with respect to any claim which may challenge the legality of our title and which is based on any occurance prior to your taking possession of the aircraft.” This appeal challenges the depth of meaning of that letter and warranty of title.

On October 7, 1974, Stewart Aviation Services of Arkansas (Stewart) filed an airplane repairman’s lien against the aircraft with the Federal Aeronautics Administration registry in Oklahoma City, alleging work done, and unpaid, in the amount of $1,167.00. The work was completed on February 22, 1974.

Buyer immediately notified seller of the lien, asking it to clear title under its “hold harmless” letter, and contends it lost a sale of the aircraft within the next few days because seller did nothing to remove the lien. Buyer paid the lien on April 23, 1975 and sold the plane shortly thereafter. Seller notified the FAA that the lien was invalid, and at no time was action brought by Stewart to foreclose the lien.

Buyer sued for the amount of the lien, plus “incidential and consequential damages” amounting to nearly $17,000.00 (interest, insurance, hangar rental, lost profits) and attorney fees. The trial court found for buyer in the amount of $1,167.00 but disallowed the other damages ruling buyer had not sought to mitigate damages by paying off the lien immediately. The trial court allowed attorney fees of $600.00 which buyer also appeals, alleging 106 hours of attorneys’ time.

Both parties appeal.

*859

I

Was the trial court correct in ruling seller breached its warranty of title by failing to remove the cloud (lien) on buyer’s title? We answer in the affirmative.

The argument reduces to two questions.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.