Ohio Court of Appeals June 26, 1981, L-80-310 (Dorf v. Sylvania Township Board of Trustees)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-06-1981
Potter, J.
This is an appeal from a judgment in favor of appellee given pursuant to R.C. Chapter 2506. The assignments of error are as follows:
“I. The Common Pleas Court Erred When It Found That Mr. Dorf Had A Statutory Right To Notice And A Hearing In This Case.
“II. The Common Pleas Court Erred When It Found That Mr. Dorf Possessed A Constitutional Right To Notice And A Hearing In This Case.
“HI. The Common Pleas Court Committed Prejudicial Error By Incorrectly Assigning The Burden Of Proof And Burden Of Going Forward With Evidence At Trial.
“IV. The Common Pleas Court Erred In Finding That The Board’s Decision Was In Retaliation For Mr. Dorf s Exercise Of A Constitutionally Protected Right.
“V. The Common Pleas Court Erred By Not Conducting A Further Hearing In Assessment Of Damages.”
We affirm the judgment for the reasons hereinafter stated but remand for determination of the amount of damageá.
The trial court has summarized the facts which led to the appeal to that court. They are, in pertinent part, as follows:
“The plaintiff-appellant was employed by Sylvania Township as a full-
*197
time township fireman on July 7,1978. On November 8, 1979, the Sylvania Board of Township Trustees, acting on the recommendation of the Sylvania Township Fire Chief, David A. Drake, terminated plaintiff-appellant’s employment with the fire department. The professed reason for Mr. Dorf s discharge was that Dorf was unable to perform his duties as a township fireman due to an off-duty injury which the plaintiff-appellant suffered sometime during July, 1979. The Board admits that it did not afford Mr. Dorf a hearing to determine the sufficiency of the cause for his discharge.
“The manner in which Mr. Dorf’s discharge was accomplished merits some attention. Although the Board did not officially terminate plaintiff-appellant’s employment until November 8, 1979, the evidence adduced at the hearing before the Court shows that on November 7, 1979, Mr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit