Court of Appeals of Texas January 21, 1981, No. 7047 (Mountain States Leasing, Inc. v. El Paso Pipe & Supply Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-01-1981
lead-opinion
OPINION
OSBORN, Justice.
This case presents the single issue as to whether a collateral attack can be made upon a prior judgment which dismissed a case for want of prosecution “with prejudice.” We have concluded that such an attack can be made, and the judgment of the trial Court must be reversed.
In April 1977, Mountain States Leasing, Inc., filed suit against the seven Defendants seeking to recover damages. On February 8, 1979, the Court entered an Order of Dismissal which recited that the “Plaintiff did not appear in person or through attorney despite notification of the time and date of the hearing.” The order decreed that the cause “be dismissed for want of prosecution, with prejudice, * * No appeal was taken from that order.
On January 25, 1980, Mountain States Leasing, Inc., and Neil Bresnahan filed suit against the same seven Defendants. All but two answered and filed a motion for summary judgment asserting the doctrine or res judicata as a result of the 1979 Order of Dismissal. Certified copies of the pleading in the original suit and the Order of Dismissal were filed in support of the motion. We assume Plaintiffs abandoned the suit as to the two Defendants that did not answer. In May, 1980, the Court granted the motion for summary judgment and entered a take nothing judgment. The Plaintiffs have perfected an appeal from that judgment.
The one Point of Error asserts the trial Court erred in determining that the former dismissal for want of prosecution was a bar *634to the subsequent suit. No complaint is made about the fact that Neil Bresnahan was not a party to the first suit.
There can be no question about the principle that a dismissal for want of prosecution is not one in which the merits of the case are determined, and it should not be “with prejudice.” Rizk v. Mayad, 603 S.W.2d 773 (Tex.1980); Freeman v. Freeman, 160 Tex. 148, 327 S.W.2d 428 (1959); Smock v. Fischel, 146 Tex. 397, 207 S.W.2d 891 (1948).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit