Court of Appeals of Texas February 26, 1981, No. 18396 (Twin Montana, Inc. v. Brazos Fuel Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-02-1981
OPINION ON MOTION FOR REHEARING
MASSEY, Chief Justice.
Our opinion on January 15, 1981 is ordered withdrawn, with the following substituted therefor.
We affirm the judgment of the trial court sustaining the plea of privilege of Brazos and transferring the suit of Twin Montana from Wise County, Texas, the county in which plaintiff believed its suit was properly maintained. Tex.Rev.Civ. Stat.Ann., art. 1995, “Venue”, subd. 14, “Lands”, (1964), which provides that suits for the recovery of lands, to quiet title to land, etc. must be brought in the county in which the land is located.
On rehearing the plaintiff, Twin Montana, has convinced us that the record does contain unrebutted proof that its suit had application to an interest in realty located in the county of suit. That proof is ordinarily the only proof necessary to be made in order to defeat a plea of privilege when the suit is shown to fall within subdivision 14 of the venue statute.
Because of that above stated disposition of the appeal is to be determined by point of error No. 4 of Twin Montana. By reference to the point, coupled with the statement and arguments made thereunder, is charged to have been so contrary to the greater weight and preponderance of the evidence as to be clearly erroneous the implied finding of the trial court that Twin Montana had failed to prove that the main purpose of the suit was to remove cloud upon its title to land or an interest therein and to quiet its title.
At the outset we will state that Twin Montana, by its theory of breach of contract on the part of Brazos Fuel, was privileged to declare upon either or both of two distinguishable causes of action. The first of these was for specific performance of the payment by Brazos of the consideration contracted — as accrued and to accrue up to time of trial. The second was for judgment for the recovery of land because of the breach by Brazos in the payments promised as consideration.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit