Court of Appeals of Georgia June 19, 1981, 61695 (Burke v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-06-1981

Shulman, Presiding Judge.

Convicted of burglary, Burke appeals, enumerating as error the refusal of the trial judge to grant a mistrial when the state placed his character in issue.

At trial, the state presented evidence that appellant was seen inside the Metro Music Centre on Roswell Road in Atlanta, after the storeowner had been alerted by a silent burglar alarm to a break-in in the early morning hours. Chasing the fleeing intruder, a police officer discovered appellant behind a dumpster in a nearby Sears parking lot. In appellant’s pocket were a guitar pick, a drum key, and a cigarette lighter, all of which were identified by the owner of the store as his property. A syringe was also found. Appellant took the stand in his own defense, testifying that he was a musician and owned the found items; that he had been waiting for a bus at the stop at the Sears parking lot after being dropped off by a friend with whom he had attended a party in the Oglethorpe area; and that he had gone behind the dumpster to shoot cocaine. On cross examination, the state elicited from appellant, over the timely objection of counsel, testimony that he had prior convictions for possession of heroin and marijuana. The trial court denied appellant’s motion for mistrial.

We consider the appellant’s objections meritorious and, accordingly, reverse. The trial court was incorrect in finding that the evidence objected to was admissible for impeachment purposes. “[A] specific denial of the crime charged [is] insufficient to generally place the defendant’s character in issue. [Cit.] Evidence of the accused’s participation in other criminal activity tended to show bad character. It did not place good character in issue so as to authorize rebuttal. [Cit.] The admission of appellant’s prior convictions constituted error requiring a new trial.” Lindler v. State, 149 Ga. App. 155 (253 SE2d 833).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.