California Court of Appeal October 19, 1981, Civ. No. 45973 (Department of Social Services v. Benjamin W.)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-10-1981

Opinion

ELKINGTON, J.

Patricia H. (Patricia) is the natural mother of Joseph E. (Joseph), a young child. She is also the natural mother of Sylvia W. (Sylvia), Joseph’s younger half-sister, whose natural father is Benjamin W. (Benjamin). On August 9, 1973, Joseph and Sylvia were adjudged dependent children of the juvenile court. Joseph was placed with foster parents in April of 1974, and Sylvia has resided in another foster home since January of 1976. The respective foster parents wish to adopt the children presently in their care.

The California State Department of Health petitioned the superior court, under Civil Code section 232, for an order declaring Joseph and Sylvia free from parental custody and control. Patricia, the mother of both, and Benjamin, the father of Sylvia, resisted the petition. Following a trial, the superior court entered judgment as prayed by the department. Patricia and Benjamin have appealed.

We affirm the judgment for the reasons as follow.

The several appellate contentions are stated as phrased by Patricia and Benjamin.

*657I. Contention: “The judgment must be reversed insofar as it severs the parental relationship between. Benjamin ... and Sylvia ... because appellant ... did not receive proper notice of the original juvenile court dependency proceeding (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 300).”

This complaint is made by Benjamin alone; Patricia had concededly received the proper notice. He contends that the superior court proceedings were invalid, because of lack of notice of “the original juvenile court dependency hearing” (italics added) several years earlier.

We observe that the claimed deficiency was not pointed out or relied upon in the superior court, and appears to be raised for the first time on this appeal; at least no contrary record reference is made. (See rule 15(a), Cal. Rules of Court.) “That the statement in the briefs of any matter in the record must be supported by an appropriate reference to the record is well established.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.