Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York June 1, 1981 (Anderson v. Regan)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-06-1981

OPINION OF THE COURT

Per Curiam.

This controversy concerns the legality of expenditures of moneys, without an appropriation by the State Legislature, received by the State from the Federal Government and held in a joint custody fund under the control of the State Comptroller and the Commissioner of Taxation and Finance. The funds are released on warrant of the Comptroller directly to State agencies upon application. The underlying action seeks a judgment declaring that such ex*491penditures violate section 7 of article VII of the New York State Constitution which provides, in pertinent part, as follows: “No money shall ever be paid out of the state treasury or any of its funds, or any of the funds under its management, except in pursuance of an appropriation by law”.

Special Term agreed with plaintiffs (107 Mise 2d 335) and granted summary judgment on the ground that defendants failed to prove that Federal funds are not subject to the constitutional mandate. This appeal ensued. We arrive at a contrary conclusion and are to reverse.

While the issue is one of broad constitutional implications, it is in fact a very narrow one. Does section 7 of article VII of the New York State Constitution mandate that such Federal grants be expended by legislative appropriation? The facts are not in dispute and we find no case dealing with the precise issue.

As a general rule, when interpreting a constitutional provision the language should be accorded its plain meaning (People v Carroll, 3 NY2d 686, 689). The fact that the provision may be unambiguous on its face, however, is rarely conclusive (see New York State Bankers Assn. v Albright, 38 NY2d 430, 436). Where aids to construction are available, their use should not be thwarted through blind adherence to the literal interpretation of provisions lacking facial ambiguity (see United States v American Trucking Assns., 310 US 534, 543-544).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.