Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York May 27, 1981 (People v. Briggs)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-05-1981
lead-opinion
— Judgment affirmed. Memorandum: On this appeal from a judgment of conviction of a felony for operating a motor vehicle with .10 of one per centum or more by weight of alcohol in his blood as a felony (Vehicle and Traffic Law, § 1192, subds 2, 5) defendant contends that the trial court erred in refusing to charge driving while ability is impaired (DWAI) (see Vehicle and Traffic Law, §1192, subd 1; §1195, subd 2, pars [b], [c]) as a lesser included offense of the charge for which he was convicted. Although section 1196 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law provides that a driver charged with operating a motor vehicle with more than the requisite per centum by weight of alcohol in his blood may be convicted of DWAI, its submission as a lesser included offense is appropriate only if there is a reasonable view of the evidence to support a DWAI finding (GPL 300.50, subd 2; see People v Farmer, 36 NY2d 386; People v Brown, 73 AD2d 112). Thus, “ ‘the question simply is whether on any reasonable view of the evidence it is possible for the trier of facts to acquit the defendant on the higher count [citations omitted] and still find him guilty on the lesser one’ ” (People v Hoag, 51 NY2d 632, 636, quoting People v Henderson, 41 NY2d 233, 236). The sole evidence concerning this count of the indictment was the blood test which indicated that the alcoholic content of his blood was .26 of one per centum. The jury could either reject or accept this evidence. The jury was thus presented with a “take it or leave it situation in which there was no evidentiary basis for a compromise finding” (People v Brown, 73 AD2d 112, supra, dissenting opn, p 116). There was no reasonable view of the evidence to support a DWAI finding since on the record the evidence excluded “every possible hypothesis” except driving while he had .10 of one per centum or more by weight of alcohol in his blood.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit