Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 3, 1981 (City School District v. McLane Construction Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-1981

Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court in favor of plaintiff, entered December 27, 1979 in Chemung County, upon a verdict rendered at Trial Term (Swartwood, J.). In 1976, the Elmira school district contracted with McLane Construction Company, Inc., for the construction of a swimming pool building which was to feature a roof consist*750ing of natural wood decking supported by laminated wood beams. The appearance of the beams was central to the aesthetics of the architectural scheme as they were to contrast their natural beauty with the relatively stark unfinished concrete that comprised the balance of the structure. Even the effectiveness of the indirect lighting system employed in the building depended on the beams. As the building was to be a showplace, the site of large regional swimmiñg competitions, the design was intentionally dramatic. It was contemplated that the beams, properly treated, would be essentially maintenance free. McLane contracted with defendant M. Matri & Sons, Inc., to supply and erect the beams. Matri in turn purchased them from Weyerhaeuser Company for delivery in August, 1976, at a contract price of $116,000. Though aware of the plans and specifications, Weyerhaeuser subcontracted for a method of treating the beams, known as the “Dow Process”, which it knew would result in staining and discoloration. There was also evidence that Weyerhaeuser failed to have the beams cleaned before the subcontractor treated them and as a consequence dirt permeated the wood. When the beams arrived in Elmira in December, 1976, Weyerhaeuser’s representative assured the school district that the clearly observable discoloration was merely road grime that could be cleaned. Based on these assurances, the school district, already in severe need of the beams to complete construction and thus protect against further loss from freezing temperatures, accepted them.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.