New York County Courts July 14, 1981 (People v. Armioia)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-07-1981

OPINION OF THE COURT

John Copertino, J.

The court has for its consideration after a hearing at which the defendant neither testified nor called witnesses the admissibility of identification testimony of William J. Collins, the only witness on this hearing, who witnessed the crime the defendant has been accused of.

The court’s findings of fact and conclusions of law follow.

At 2:00 a.m. on February 10, 1981, William J. Collins took his taxicab to the Armory Pub to collect its bartender, Mr. William Phillips. Upon arriving in front of the premises he — as per usual — saw that the pub’s exterior lights were out, sounded the horn and waited in his cab — as was his wont — for Mr. Phillips to emerge. No one exited the pub. At this point, Collins noticed a black male standing at a corner nearby the premises in question. Collins then saw the male go to the front door of the premises, look in, and then approach the Collins vehicle. The black male asked Collins for a cigarette and then informed him that “Captain Bill” — as Phillips was referred to — would not be needing a “cab” for about one-half hour. The black male departed and when he was about one-half block from *1039Collins, the latter went to the door of the pub and looked into the pub through the door’s diamond-shaped light and saw a white man about six feet two inches tall weighing about 180 pounds with light brown hair, wearing a red and white plaid shirt standing over a man on the floor and holding the latter’s shirt with one hand and a wooden bar stool in the other. A struggle was going on but the man on the floor was the worse for it. From this perspective Collins could not see the face of the man holding the stool inasmuch as his back was to Collins, nor could he see who the man on the floor was.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.