Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York October 27, 1981 (People v. Lawrence)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-10-1981
OPINION OF THE COURT
Thomas R. Jones, J.
The defendant, Harry Lawrence, has appealed from a judgment convicting him, after a nonjury trial, of the crime of sexual abuse in the third degree, a class B misdemeanor (Penal Law, § 130.55), and a sentence of one-year probation, on the ground that his conviction was based upon evidence that did not establish his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt (US Const, 14th Arndt; NY Const, art I, § 6).
Except for the testimony of the complainant, Rosia Cruz, that she was sexually molested by the accused on a busy New York subway train, no corroborative evidence was *1028presented to prove that the defendant committed any act of sexual abuse on the person of the alleged victim. This “pure” identification case, i.e., one in which there was no corroboration of the crime or the defendant’s connection with it, highlights the great dangers of misidentification of innocent persons which have haunted criminal justice from ancient times to the present. Apart from the alleged victim’s account of her experience on the subway train, no independent evidence was introduced which connected the accused with the crime; no proof was presented that confirmed, in any material particular, not only the evidence that the crime was committed but also that the defendant committed it. A careful examination of all of the evidence in the case, including the unchallenged testimony of the defendant’s good character given by one witness, and the exculpatory testimony of another, compels the conclusion that the guilt of the defendant was not established beyond a reasonable doubt.
A young Hispanic woman, the sole eyewitness in this case, testified that as she boarded a busy “GG” subway train at Broadway, Brooklyn, on the afternoon of October 17,1979, she suddenly felt a hand between her legs, thrust from behind, that touched her vagina. The complainant, Rosia Cruz, was wearing a nurse’s uniform and pants or slacks, and an overcoat that reached her knees.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit