Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania July 24, 1981, Appeal, No. 2215 C.D. 1979 (El v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-07-1981

Opinion by

Judge Blatt,

The claimant1 appeals here from an order of the Board2 which affirmed a referee’s denial of benefits under Section 402(e) of the Pennsylvania Unemployment Compensation Law (Act)3 because of willful misconduct.4

During his nearly six years of employment as a bus driver for the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority, the claimant had received several warnings and two suspensions for violating the employer’s rules, and, following supervisors’ reports of three separate infractions during his last full week of work,5 he was suspended pending discharge. The employer’s representative (representative) then conducted two hearings at which the claimant, in the presence of his union delegates, was interviewed as to the reports, and his overall record was reviewed. He was then discharged.

*60At the hearing before the referee, the representative testified that the claimant had been discharged because of a generally substandard record culminating in the commission of the three dischargeable offenses. He further testified that he had not witnessed the three incidents and that his knowledge of them was based solely on the supervisors’ reports and the claimant’s responses to them. The claimant’s attorney objected to the representative’s testimony as hearsay. An interoffice memorandum of May 3, 1979, in which the representative had outlined the events leading up to the claimant’s discharge was also received into evidence over the objections of the claimant’s attorney. The referee and the Board denied benefits and this appeal followed.

Section 402(e) of the Act provides that an employee shall be ineligible for unemployment compensation benefits during any week in which “his unemployment is due to his discharge or temporary suspension from work for willful misconduct connected with his work” and whether or not the claimant’s conduct rises to the level of willful misconduct is a question of law. Kentucky Fried Chicken of Altoona, Inc. v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.