Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania December 30, 1981, Appeal, No. 2259 C.D. 1980 (Dunmire v. Applied Business Controls, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1981

Opinion by

Judge MacPhail,

John Dunmire, Esquire, and James Cassel, Esquire (Petitioners) seek to appeal an order of the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, which granted Applied Business Controls, Inc. (Respondent) motion for summary judgment against the Petitioners.

The Petitioners are attorneys engaged in the practice of law and are partners in a law firm which has its principal office in the Borough of Norristown, Pennsylvania, with branch offices located in the City of Philadelphia and the Borough of Jenkintown. The Respondent is the local tax collector of earned income taxes for the Borough of Norristown, the Norristown Area School District and the Township of East Norriton.

The Respondent, plaintiff below, commenced two actions in assumpsit for the collection of taxes alleg*481edly due and owing by the Petitioners, defendants below. The Respondent prevailed before the district justice in both actions. The Petitioners appealed to the Court of Common Pleas where their cases were consolidated. Based on the facts to which the parties stipulated, cross motions for summary judgment were filed. The motion was granted as to the Respondent and denied as to the Petitioners.

The relevant facts to which the parties stipulated follow: The Borough of Norristown imposes a one per cent earned income tax on both residents and nonresidents working within its territorial limits. The Norristown Area School District imposes a one per cent earned income tax on residents living within that-school district and the Township of East Norriton imposes a one per cent earned income tax on all residents of the township.1

It is not disputed that Petitioners Dunmire and Cassel were proper objects of the taxes imposed. Petitioner Dunmire, although not a resident of the Borough of Norristown, or the Norristown Area School District, was working within the Borough of Norris-town and therefore subject to being taxed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.