Supreme Court of Virginia September 11, 1981, Record No. 790813 (City of Martinsville v. Board of Supervisors)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-09-1981

COMPTON, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

In this appeal, we consider whether a city may properly exercise its common-law right to sell surplus water in an adjoining county without the county’s authorization and consent.

Appellee Board of Supervisors of Henry County filed in December of 1978 a motion for declaratory judgment against appellant City Council of the City of Martinsville seeking a determination of the rights of the parties for providing water service within the County. The motion asserted the City Council had authorized a water connection to Frith Construction Company for service outside the City and within the County in the area of a specific water project of the Henry County Public Service Authority.

The trial court entered ex parte a temporary injunction restraining the City for a period of 30 days from connecting the proposed service. Subsequently, the Authority intervened on the County’s side of the case and sought to have the injunction made permanent. Further, the Authority asked the court to declare it had the sole and exclusive jurisdiction for providing water service in the County.

In January of 1979, an ore tenus hearing was held and the temporary injunction was extended. Later, the trial court ruled against the City and made the injunction permanent but permitted the connection to be made and City water to be used by Frith pending any appeal. Subsequently, we granted the City an appeal from the March 1979 final judgment in favor of the County and the Authority.

The facts are undisputed. At the time of the hearing, the City’s water treatment plan and water supply system had a daily surplus of 1.7 million gallons. For a number of years the City had sold a portion of the surplus to County customers using a water supply system with water mains laid in the County. The mains were laid in 1963 to serve an industrial park situated in the County on land then owned by the City.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.