Supreme Court of Alabama February 20, 1981, No. 79-954 (Collins v. Bankers Life & Casualty Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-02-1981

SHORES, Justice.

This case is before this Court on the petition of Marie Collins seeking a writ of mandamus requiring the trial court to vacate its order striking Collins’s demand for jury trial in the proceedings below. We deny the relief sought.

*953Ralph E. Slate, a practicing attorney in Morgan County, instituted an attorney’s lien enforcement suit under the authority of § 34-3-61, Code of Alabama 1975. Collins made a demand for a jury trial, which Slate moved to strike. The trial judge granted the motion, finding that there was no right to a jury trial in a suit to enforce an attorney’s lien.

The only issue presented is whether the petitioner is entitled to a jury trial as a matter of right after the adoption of the Alabama Rules of Civil Procedure, by which law and equity were merged into one form of action.

Rule 38(a), ARCP, preserves the right to a trial by jury in cases which would have been tried to a jury, if demanded, under prior procedure. This is the one procedural difference which remains under the Rule. Thus, the case turns upon whether an action to enforce an attorney’s lien was one which was triable to a jury as a matter of right before the adoption of the Rules. The petitioner conceded before the trial court that prior to the adoption of the Rules of Civil Procedure, attorney’s fee lien suits were deemed to be equitable in nature, and a jury trial was not allowable as a matter of right. In Peach v. Drennen, 253 Ala. 271, 44 So.2d 257 (1950), this Court held that § 1, Title 33, Code of 1940 [now § 35-11-1, Code of 1975], applied to attorney’s liens. Section 1, Title 33, provides that “[a]ny lien may be enforced in the manner provided by statute, if so provided, or in equity....”

Section 34-3-61, Code, provides for attorney’s liens in limited cases. This statute does not, however, provide for a method of enforcement. Thus, under § 35-11-1, the only method of enforcement of attorney’s liens prior to the adoption of the ARCP was by a bill in equity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.