Louisiana Court of Appeal April 7, 1981, No. 12013 (Guidry v. Cheramie)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-04-1981

JULIAN E. BAILES, Judge Pro Tem.

Plaintiffs-appellants appeal the judgment of the trial court dismissing their action to recover damages for physical injuries and medical expenses from the defendant-appel-lee dance hall owner sustained when plaintiff-appellant wife slipped and fell on the dance hall floor.

During discovery depositions and at trial neither the husband nor wife appellant could identify the alleged foreign substance which allegedly caused Mrs. Guidry to slip. During her testimony in chief she states the floor was slippery and that “I don’t know what I slipped on, but I felt like little gravels or something_whatever it was.” At trial the plaintiff-husband testified, as on deposition, that he didn’t know what caused his wife to fall.

In addition to the testimony of the appellants, Mr. and Mrs. Guidry, a Mr. Yancy Cheramie testified that he was in the dance hall at the time Mrs. Guidry fell and that he saw no substance on the floor when he helped pick up Mrs. Guidry.

The defendant-appellee testified under cross-examination as follows:

“Q. Okay, do you know if you spray or if you ever put any powder on the floor to make it a little slippery to make people dance better?

“MR. CHERAMIE (INTERPRETING):

Answer: She says she puts a little bit but not plenty. And she said people *873complain because she does not put enough.

“Q. But there was some on the floor?

“MR. CHERAMIE: She said that they had some on the floor but not enough to make anybody fall.

“No further questions.”

Appellant argues that “All that is needed to prove out a case of slip and fall is that there must be a foreign substance on the floor, and that this substance caused plaintiff’s injury. Champagne v. Harahan Lions Club, Inc., 243 So.2d 292 (La.App.1971). Clearly, this was established in this cause and the case should have continued to a close of all evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.