District Court of Appeal of Florida July 8, 1981, No. 80-2088 (Kinney v. Allied Home Builders, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-07-1981

SCHEB, Chief Judge.

Michael J. and Margaret A. Kinney challenge a final judgment awarding Allied Home Builders, Inc., an equitable lien on undisbursed mortgage loan proceeds.

Dr. and Mrs. Kinney contracted with Allied to build them a residence on their land. The Kinneys obtained their construction financing from Coast Federal Savings & Loan Association. During construction a dispute arose between Allied and the Kin-neys over “extra charges.” As a result, the Kinneys refused to authorize Coast Federal to pay Allied the final draw on the loan proceeds. Allied then filed a claim of lien against their property, and the Kinneys, in turn, filed a suit against Allied contending that its claim of lien was a willfully exaggerated one. Allied answered the complaint, but it did not seek any affirmative relief against the Kinneys, their land or the undisbursed loan proceeds remaining with Coast Federal. The litigation terminated with a final judgment in favor of Allied. Subsequently, Allied filed a new suit seeking to foreclose its claim of lien. The court entered a summary final judgment in favor of the Kinneys in the second suit on the ground that Allied’s failure to have filed a counterclaim in the initial litigation barred it from recovery against the Kinneys.

Allied next proceeded to file the present suit seeking an equitable lien on the remaining undisbursed loan proceeds. The court awarded Allied a judgment and directed that the undisbursed sums, then deposited in the registry of the court, be paid to Allied. This appeal by the Kinneys ensued.

Although Allied sought in this litigation to impose an equitable lien on the construction loan proceeds,1 the Kinneys urge that in reality Allied’s claim is an action for sums due under the construction contract. Consequently, they argue, Allied’s claim is barred as it was the subject of a compulsory counterclaim in the exaggerated lien-claim action.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.