Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama May 6, 1981, Civ. 2526 (Winn-Dixie Kwik Chek v. Travis)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-1981

WRIGHT, Presiding Judge.

Defendant appeals from a judgment awarding $7,500 to plaintiff for injuries allegedly resulting from a “slip and fall.”

The dispositive issue is whether the evidence produced on behalf of plaintiff, Bill *955Travis, was sufficient to support a finding of negligence on the part of defendant, Winn-Dixie. We find the evidence insufficient to support such a finding and reverse.

Our decision in a recent “slip and fall” case, Winn-Dixie Store No. 1501 v. Daisy Brown, 394 So.2d 49 (Ala.Civ.App., 1981), which likewise turned on the sufficiency of the plaintiffs proof, set forth the following:

In slip and fall cases, as in all negligence cases, the plaintiff has the burden of establishing by the evidence the negligence of the defendant. 15 Ala.Dig., Negligence, Key No. 121.1(8) ....

It is well settled that the duty upon the storekeeper, in a case such as this, is to exercise reasonable care in providing and maintaining reasonably safe premises for the use of the customer. Foodtown Stores, Inc. v. Patterson, 282 Ala. 477, 213 So.2d 211 (1968). The storekeeper is not an insurer of the customer’s safety while on the premises, but is liable for injury only in the event he negligently fails to use reasonable care in maintaining his premises in a reasonably safe condition. Delchamps, Inc. v. Stewart, 47 Ala.App. 406, 255 So.2d 586, cert. denied, 287 Ala. 729, 255 So.2d 592 (1971).

As the burden of showing negligence rests with the plaintiff, it is necessary to prove: (a) that the foreign substance slipped upon was on the floor a sufficient length of time to impute constructive notice to the defendant, or (b) that the defendant had actual notice of the substance’s presence on the floor, or (c) that the defendant was delinquent in not discovering and removing the foreign substance. In the absence of such proof, the plaintiff has not made out a prima facie case that the defendant was negligent in the maintenance of its floors. S. H. Kress & Co. v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.