United States District Court December 18, 1981, No. SR-CV-188-81 (Bryant v. Bryant)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-12-1981
OPINION AND ORDER
Honorable Harry D. Brown, Judge presiding.
The problem before the court is whether additional damages should be granted in a judgment following a jury verdict. This is a case where a nine year old young lady and a fourteen year old young man were killed in an automobile collision. The verdict of the jury awarded $25,000 for damages arising from the deaths of each child. That award is challenged as being inadequate on the grounds of inadequacy as compared with the jury's other awards ($25,000 for a leg injury to one survivor of the collision and $25,000 for a head injury sustained by another) and a failure of the jury to understand or accept the uncontradicted testimony of a witness who is an expert in the field of economic losses caused by an individual's death.
The standard to be applied to the motion is the same as that applied in situations where a party seeks a new trial. The party basing a motion on inadequate damages must not only show the damages were lower than is justified by the evidence presented in the case, but that the damages are unconscionably low, bear no reasonable relationship to the evidence and the verdict would work a clear injustice to the party. Schuerholz v. Roach, 58 F.2d 32 (4th Cir. 1932); Mc Figg, et.al., Civil Trial Manual p. 471 (ALI/ABA 1976).
This is a situation where there was a jury trial. It has always been understood that jurors will bring their experience, culture and community standards into the jury box. The plaintiffs complain that the jury disregarded or misunderstood the expert witness. While the court is unable to read the jurors' minds, if they, indeed did not understand the expert witness, perhaps that is the fault of the witness and counsel. The plaintiffs had plenty of opportunity to get their points across through testimony, jury instructions and argument. But perhaps the jury did understand the expert witness and applied their community knowledge.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit