Supreme Court of South Carolina June 9, 1981, 21485 (Southeastern Mobile Homes, Inc. v. Pittman)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-06-1981
Harwell, Justice:
Appellant Southeastern Mobile Homes, Inc. commenced an action for claim and delivery of a new mobile home against the respondents Pittman who requested a presei-zure hearing on the matter. Prior to the requested hearing the parties agreed to' a consent order which allowed Southeastern to take possession of the mobile home and which also allowed the parties to file new pleadings in the suit. Thereafter, appellant filed an amended complaint seeking a deficiency judgment from the respondents. The Pittmans in turn answered and counterclaimed for, inter alia, a rescission of the mobile home sales agreement.
During trial below, the trial judge granted the respondents’ motion for involuntary nonsuit as to Southeastern’s claim for a deficiency. The counterclaim for rescission went to the jury; the jury returned its verdict for the Pittmans on this claim. Southeastern’s motions for an involuntary nonsuit, a directed verdict and for judgment non obstante veredicto were all denied. Southeastern contends that the trial judge erred as to all these matters. We disagree.
It is axiomatic that appellant’s motions for judgment as a matter of law could be properly granted only if the counterclaim for rescission had not been *434made out or if no jury issue had been presented. Mack v. West, S. C, 272 S. E. (2d) 631 (1980); Jamison v. Howard, S. C., 271 S. E. (2d) 116 (1980). Here, the respondents presented testimony that the mobile home was improperly installed, had a leaking roof, had water damaged carpet which emitted a mildew odor and was separatéd in places, had split paneling in two rooms and was caved in in places. In addition, the respondents testified that Southeastern’s representative promised h> have storm windows, electricity and plumbing installed, to have the home decorated, and tO' furnish a certain make of refrigerator. These promises were not fulfilled. The Pittmans’ efforts to resolve the problems over a period of several weeks proved futile.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit