United States Court of Claims January 23, 1981, No. 254-79C (Parker)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-01-1981

The plaintiff in this case challenges his removal from his position as a veterinarian with the Meat and Poultry Inspection Service of the United States Department of Agriculture for accepting free meals and drinks from a meat packing plant at which he worked as a relief meat inspector. Both parties moved for summary judgment, and we heard oral argument. We sustain plaintiffs discharge.

I.

In 1978, the plaintiff received a written notice proposing to remove him from his position for "acceptance of things of value from persons with whom you have an official relationship,” in violation of the "Employee Responsibility and Conduct” appendix to the Employee Handbook of the Department of Agriculture (36 Fed. Reg. 414 (1971) (current version at 7 C.F.R. § 0.735-12 (1980))). More specifically, the notice alleged that during three different 5-day periods in 1975, he accepted free meals on an average of two or three times a week and one or two drinks of liquor each such day from a specified meat packing plant at which he performed inspection duties.1

Plaintiff submitted both a written and an oral response to an oral conference officer, Dr. Elliott. The plaintiff admitted accepting the meals and drinks in 1975, but attempted *609to justify his conduct as a means for improving the relationship between the plant management and the federal inspectors. The oral reply officer concluded that the plaintiff had accepted the meals and drinks as charged. The oral reply officer interpreted the Department of Agriculture’s "Penalty Guide” for supervisors as requiring discharge as the penalty for improper acceptance of gratuities by employees. He recommended, however, that "[i]f it is possible to take action other than provided in the Penalty Guide,” the plaintiff should be retained in the service but suspended without pay for at least two pay periods.

The personnel officer, Mr. Zimmer, removed the plaintiff from his position. In taking that action, Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.