United States Court of Claims June 3, 1981, No. 326-K (Western Shoshone Identifiable Group ex rel. Temoak Bands of Western Shoshone Indians v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-06-1981
BENNETT, Judge,
delivered the opinion of the court:
This case comes before the court on two requests for review of the opinion and decision filed November 13,1980, by Trial Judge James F. Merow, in the matter of a claim for *28attorneys’ fees. The first request, filed December 15,1980, is submitted by the claims attorneys who won a judgment of $26,145,189.89 for plaintiffs before the Indian Claims Commission.1 The trial judge awarded the attorneys a fee of 9.1 percent of the judgment, or $2,379,212.19. The claims attorneys seek instead a fee of 10 percent of the judgment, or $2,614,518.99, the maximum allowed by statute for Indian claims cases. The difference is $235,306.80. Reimbursement of attorney expenses of $44,010.34 as ordered by the trial judge is not put in issue by the claims attorneys. The defendant United States advises the court that it considers the trial judge’s decision to be correct.
The second request for review was filed on December 18, 1980, by the attorney for the Duckwater Shoshone Tribe, the Battle Mountain Indian Community, and the Western Shoshone Sacred Lands Association, jointly hereafter referred to as "Duckwater.” The Association is not one of the 21 federally recognized Shoshone Bands. This request asks review of the trial judge’s decision dismissing Duckwater’s opposition to the award which it challenges since it considers that the claims attorneys are not entitled to a fee because of alleged unethical conduct in manipulating, suppressing, and opposing the wishes of their clients in some 17 different particulars.
We reject Duckwater’s request and we reject the conclusion of the trial judge on the fee, and award the claims attorneys a full 10-percent fee for reasons which will be explained. First, however, it is necessary to state the facts leading up to this fee controversy in some detail, to put our conclusion in proper perspective. In so doing, we borrow freely from the careful recital of such matters by the trial judge.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit