United States Court of Claims June 26, 1981, No. 250-77 (Orthopedic Equipment Co. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-1981

per curiam:

This is apparently a major case, brought under 28 U.S.C. §1498 to recover reasonable and entire compensation for infringement of a patent covering a Business Order Control System and Apparatus. All three armed services are alleged infringers. Presumably, if defendant is liable, it will be so for substantial sums. Yet counsel have dropped other pursuits to bury this panel in interlocutory paper concerning defendant’s liability to pay the relatively minor sum of $1,181.25, under circumstances that will appear.

The issue presented in this motion for stay is whether witness deposition costs assessed against a party by a trial judge must be paid when assessed or need not be paid until this court exercises final review under Rule 53(c), whether deferred or interlocutory. For the reasons discussed herein, we hold such costs are not due until this court issues a final judgment in the case.

This case is before the court on the motion of the defendant United States Government to stay Trial Judge Colaianni’s order of April 24, 1981, requiring that defendant pay plaintiffs the $1,181.25 by May 9,1981.

*736On December 15,1978, defendant filed a motion for leave pursuant to Rule 81(b) to take the deposition of plaintiffs’ expert witness Mr. Nikolai. The government offered to pay the deponent’s reasonable and necessary expenses associated with the deposition. Because of this, the trial judge permitted the deposition over plaintiffs’ objections that the deposition imposed an undue burden. In assessing costs, the trial judge determined that the reasonable and necessary costs defendant owed consisted of the deponent’s expenses plus costs attributable to the government’s use of the expert in developing its own case beyond simply learning from the expert about plaintiffs’ case. See 48 F.R.D. 487, 504. The trial judge found the defendant owed $562 for the former category, and $1,500 for the latter. Order of March 23,1979.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.