United States Court of Claims August 14, 1981, No. 161-79L (Zuni Tribe of New Mexico v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-08-1981
The issue presented is whether the trial judge erred in refusing to consider plaintiffs pretrial motion for an order specifying it need not prove exclusive use at trial to succeed on the merits. The trial judge viewed that motion as beyond her purview and referred it here. For the reasons discussed herein, we take no position on the merits of plaintiffs motion, but do reverse and hold that the motion was properly before the trial judge. The matter is therefore remanded in accordance with the procedure discussed here.
Section 2(a) of the Act of May 15,1978, Pub.L. No. 95-280, 92 Stat. 44 (Act), conferred jurisdiction upon the court to render judgment on any claims of the Zuni Indian Tribe of New Mexico against the United States "with respect to any lands or interests therein in the State of New Mexico or the State of Arizona held by aboriginal title or otherwise which were acquired from the tribe without payment of adequate compensation by the United States.” Absent this Act, plaintiff Zuni Tribe’s petition would have been time barred. In its petition the Zuni Tribe claimed substantial tracts of land by aboriginal title that the Indian Claims Commission had already adjudged as belonging to the Navajo Tribe.
On September 17,1979, defendant United States Government moved to consolidate this case with the aboriginal claims of the Navajo Tribe. On January 25,1980, this court denied defendant’s motion to consolidate. Navajo Tribe v. United States, No. 229 and the Zuni Indian Tribe of New Mexico v. United States, No. 161-79L, 222 Ct.Cl. 584 (1980). The government had argued that consolidation was proper because aboriginal title requires a finding of exclusive use *846and occupancy of definite lands. E.g., United States v. Santa Fe Pacific Railroad Co., 314 U.S. 339, 345 (1941). The government contended that the two overlapping claims of the Navajo and Zuni Tribes should be consolidated and tried in one action.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit