Frederick County Circuit Court July 2, 1981, Case No. (Chancery) 6377 (Reel v. Reel)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-07-1981
By JUDGE ROBERT K. WOLTZ
Complainant alleges in this case that she and defendant are husband and wife residing together, that defendant has "ceased supporting her" and that in conjunction with certain present acts, if he carries out threats to desert her, she will be left without means of support, and asks for support and maintenance from him.
The defendant demurs on the grounds that the parties are still "co-habitating" and living together as man and wife, that the allegation the defendant has ceased supporting the complainant is in conflict with the allegations of threats to desert and leave without means of support and that the cause is premature.
The first point of the demurrer, though not objected to, is in the nature of a "speaking demurrer" in that it makes allegations of fact. To that extent it will be considered as a part of defendant’s answer, but in the interest of resolution of issues will . be treated as a demurrer to the complainant’s allegation that the parties presently are residing together.
So taken, this point of the demurrer is overruled as in my opinion the fact that husband and wife reside under the same roof does not as a matter of law foreclose *483her maintaining an action for support and maintenance. Rather it depends on the facts as to the degree and extent they are or are not cohabiting there and living together as man and wife.
While alimony is allowed as an incident to divorce, equity has inherent power to grant it in an independent suit. Latham v. Latham, 71 Va. (30 Gratt.) 337 (1878). Alimony is not merely an incident of divorce, it is a substantial right which can be enforced by inherent equity power independent of statute. White v. White, 181 Va. 162 (1943). See also 41 Am. Jur. 2d, Husband and Wife, § 387, and Phelps, Domestic Relations in Virginia (1977), § 11-1. Furthermore, the husband has the legal and moral duty to support "whether or not the wife is destitute and in necessitous circumstances." Bundy v. Bundy, 197 Va.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit