New Jersey Tax Court November 6, 1981 (Atlantic Cape May Package Store Ass'n v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-11-1981

RIMM, J. T. C.

This matter involves an attack on the constitutionality of the Alcoholic Beverage Wholesale Sales Tax Act, N.J.S.A. 54:32C-1 et. seq., and the Atlantic City luxury tax. It is before the court on the separate motions of each defendant to dismiss the complaint, and the cross-motion of plaintiffs for summary judgment.

Plaintiffs are, respectively, a nonprofit corporation comprised of 22 retail sellers of packaged alcoholic beverages in Atlantic and Cape May Counties, eight of which are in Atlantic City; a retail seller of packaged alcoholic beverages in Atlantic City, and the president of that retail seller.

On August 1, 1980 the Alcoholic Beverage Wholesale Sales Tax Act went into effect imposing a tax of 6.5% upon the receipts from every sale of alcoholic beverages, except draft beer sold by the barrel, by any wholesaler to any retail seller. The wholesaler is required to collect this tax from the retail seller when collecting the receipts to which it applies.

Defendant Atlantic City (hereafter “city”) imposes a 4% luxury tax on the receipts from sales of packaged alcoholic beverages by any retail seller in the city. The retail seller is required to collect this tax from the ultimate consumer when collecting the receipts to which it applies.

Prior to August 1, 1980 retail sellers of packaged alcoholic beverages in the city whose sales were subject to the luxury tax did not pay both the luxury tax and the State’s 5% sales tax imposed on the retail sales of packaged alcoholic beverages. Retail sellers in the city were required to pay the 4% luxury tax to the city and a 1% sales tax to the State on sales of packaged *471alcoholic beverages for a total of 5%, equal to the sales tax imposed on the sale of packaged alcoholic beverages in the rest of the State.

The 6.5% wholesale sales tax replaced the 5% sales tax to the extent that the latter tax applied to the sale of alcoholic beverages.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.