Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Crawford County April 24, 1981, no. 266 of 1979 (Kinney v. Travelers Insurance Companies)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-04-1981

THOMAS, P.J.,

This is an assumpsit action brought by the surviving spouse of a motor vehicle accident victim to recover that decedent’s work loss benefits in accordance with the terms of the Pennsylvania No-fault Motor Vehicle Insurance Act.1 Although a survivor’s basic right to recover such work loss benefits has been affirmatively decided by the Supreme Court in Allstate Insurance Co. v. Heffner, 491 Pa. 447, 421 A. 2d 629 (1980), this action raises various issues incidental to, and thus undecided by, the Heffner opinion.

*106FACTS

Plaintiff is the surviving spouse of Roy E. Allen, who was fatally injured in an automobile accident of February 27,1977. At the time of his death, Allen was insured by defendant, Travelers Insurance Companies, in accordance with the terms of the No-fault Act.

Plaintiff subsequently applied for benefits under decedent’s policy, claiming funeral expenses, survivor’s loss and work loss benefits. Defendant paid the claimed funeral expenses and survivor’s loss but denied the work loss benefits. Thereafter, plaintiff filed this action in assumpsit to recover the work loss benefits and has now moved for summary judgment.

DISCUSSION

We note initially that the entry of summary judgment is proper here in that there exists no genuine issue as to any material fact: Toth v. Philadelphia, 213 Pa. Superior Ct. 282, 247 A. 2d 629 (1968). Instead, only the controlling principles of law are in dispute.

The thrust of defendant’s contention is that the Heffner decision, supra, should be applied prospectively only; thus only the survivors of deceased victims killed after the September 22, 1980 filing date of that opinion could recover work loss benefits. Contending that a work loss benefit for deceased victims was not clearly evident from the face of the No-fault Act, defendant alleges that the retroactive inclusion of that type of loss would be grossly unfair to the insurance industry because the current rate structures do not anticipate such losses.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.