Arizona Supreme Court October 8, 1982, 16079-SA (Korman v. Strick)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-10-1982

GORDON, Vice Chief Justice:

Petitioner David J. Korman brings this special action from a contempt finding against him by the respondent judge. Having taken jurisdiction under Ariz. Const. Art. 6, § 5(1), we vacate the jail sentence imposed on petitioner.

Petitioner’s wife filed for a dissolution of their marriage in February, 1981. In connection with the dissolution proceeding, she made several discovery requests with which petitioner did not comply. Petitioner’s wife then obtained court orders compelling discovery, but petitioner failed to fully comply with these orders. Finally, petitioner’s wife filed a motion to compel discovery and requested sanctions against petitioner. The respondent judge granted the motion on March 10, 1982 and ordered petitioner to pay his wife $500 for attorney’s fees incurred in bringing the motion. Respondent gave petitioner until April 30, 1982 to pay the money.

Petitioner did not pay, and his wife petitioned on May 10,1982 for an order to show cause why he should not be held in contempt for nonpayment. A hearing took place on June 2, 1982. Respondent found petitioner in contempt and ordered him to serve a 30 day jail sentence. When asked by petitioner’s counsel if the contempt could be purged by payment of the $500 due, respondent replied, “The time to purge was when I ordered him to pay.” Respondent then added, “I made that order * * * not as a hammer to get $500.00,1 made it because of the offense to this Court, not [petitioner’s wife’s counsel], not [petitioner’s wife], but the dignity of this Court. The time to pay it was when he was ordered to pay it.”

Petitioner was allowed to bring a motion for rehearing on June 3. It is uncontested that petitioner did pay the $500 on June 2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.