Hawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals October 4, 1982, NO. 7803 (Rosa v. Johnston)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-10-1982
*421
OPINION OF THE COURT BY
TANAKA, J.
In a jury-waived trial, the court below rendered a money judgment in favor of plain tiffs-appellees Hiram Rosa and Myrna L. Rosa (Rosas) and against defendant-appellant CWJ Corporation, Ltd., dba Solar Hawaii (CWJ), for breach of contract and for unfair and deceptive trade practices. The court dismissed the complaint as to defendant-appellant Charles W. Johnston (Johnston), but entered an order denying him attorney’s fee and costs. CWJ and Johnston appeal from such judgment and order.
The appeals involve the following issues:
1. Whether CWJ failed to prove its affirmative defense of accord and satisfaction.
2. Whether the court’s determination that CWJ committed unfair and deceptive trade practices was proper.
3. Whether the court properly awarded costs of$l,066.95 to Rosas.
4. Whether the court properly denied Johnston’s request for attorney’s fee and costs.
We answer yes to issues 1 and 2 and affirm, but answer no to issues 3 and 4 and reverse and remand.
On or about October 30, 1978, Rosas and CWJ entered into a contract for the purchase and installation of a thermo-syphon type of solar water heating unit with a storage tank.
On November 14, 1978, the solar water heating system was installed. Simultaneously, the existing electric water heater was removed. During the installation, John W. Gale, an employee of CWJ,
*422
informed his employer that the system as designed would never provide hot water to the occupants of Rosas’ home. Despite such notification, CWJ instructed that the installation be completed as designed.
As designed and installed, the system failed to provide hot water between November 14,1978 andjanuary 4,1979. Rosas called CWJ almost daily requesting repairs.
On November 23, 1978, Gale made a service call. He informed Rosas that the system could not be repaired to provide hot water.
On November 27,1978, Adam Pilakowski and George Medeiros, both employees of CWJ, met Rosas at their home.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit