Court of Appeals of Arizona February 26, 1982, 2 CA-CIV 4178 (Gamburg v. Cooper)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-02-1982

OPINION

HOWARD, Chief Judge.

The issue in this case is whether the trial court erred in ruling that appellants, as owners of a servient estate, could not put gates across an easement for ingress and egress.

The parties are adjacent landowners with the property of appellants being due west of appellees’ property. Since 1947 appellees have had a perpetual easement by grant for ingress and egress along the south 15 feet and west 30 feet of appellants’ property. In 1978 appellants put a gate across the 30-foot easement and one across the 15-foot easement. This caused a dispute between the parties and a great deal of animosity. Prior to 1978 no gates had ever existed across the easements.

Appellants filed a complaint in the superior court alleging that the appellees failed to keep the gates closed, damaged the gates and caused other damages by failing to keep the gates closed. Appellees counterclaimed alleging several counts for damages and asking the court to issue a mandatory injunction requiring appellants to remove the gates. A hearing was held on each parties’ request for a preliminary injunction. The trial court denied appellants preliminary injunctive relief, but granted such relief to appellees and ordered that appellants be enjoined from obstructing the existing easement by gates or any other obstruction.

Approximately two years later the case went to trial. The parties stipulated that all testimony and the transcript of the prior preliminary injunction proceeding could be used by the court in making its determination on the issues. After a two-day trial the court, sitting without a jury, found in favor of appellees and against appellants on the appellees’ counterclaim. The court ordered that appellants remove any and all fences, gates or other obstructions from the easement and permanently enjoined them from obstructing the easement by gates, water or any other type of obstruction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.