Court of Appeals of North Carolina October 19, 1982, 8110IC1245 (Durham v. McLamb)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-10-1982

JOHNSON, Judge.

The evidence in this case shows that in December, 1979, defendant hired plaintiff, Bill Wood, Terry Batchelor, and Roy Russ to perform carpentry work, subflooring, and framing for approximately four houses built by defendant for rental purposes. Defendant hired plaintiff, Wood, Batchelor, and Russ as self-employed carpenters who provided their own tools. Plaintiff,

*167

although he never talked to defendant about it, assumed he was self-employed. However, despite plaintiffs assumption that he was self-employed, he never advertised his services as a carpenter and never hired anyone to help him with a job. Defendant had plenty of carpentry work to be done, but discharged the workers in early January, 1980 because defendant did not have money to pay for additional work. Plaintiff, Wood, Batchelor, and Russ kept their own time and were paid individually on a hourly and weekly basis by check drawn on defendant’s account. Plaintiff worked full-time for defendant from the time he was hired until early January, 1980. There were some days when all of the men did not work because of bad weather.

Defendant visited the job site once or twice daily to give the workers instructions as to what jobs he wanted done. The workers were skilled in their work and did not require specific instructions on how to do the job. Defendant did not deduct any withholding taxes from the workers’ pay. The workers received the following pay until their discharge in early January, 1980:

Week ending 13 December 1979

Plaintiff $180.00

Terry Batchelor $100.00

Roy Russ $130.90

Bill Wood $150.00

Week ending 21 December 1979

Plaintiff $240.00

Roy Russ $216.00

Bill Wood $122.50

Week ending 28 December 1979

Plaintiff $138.00

Terry Batchelor $155.00

Roy Russ $ 96.75

Week ending 4 January 1980

Plaintiff $180.00

Terry Batchelor $125.00

Roy Russ $148.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.