Court of Appeals of Georgia October 25, 1982, 64574 (Nelson v. Smothers)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-10-1982

Carley, Judge.

Appellant-Nelson brought an action seeking specific performance of an option to repurchase property that he had sold to appellee-Smothers. A verdict was returned for Nelson and the judgment entered on this verdict was affirmed in

Smothers v. Nelson,

246 Ga. 216 (271 SE2d 137) (1980). During the pendency of the appeal, Smothers remained in possession of the property. Sometime after the remittitur of the Supreme Court was returned to the trial court and Smothers had reconveyed the property, Nelson instituted the instant action. Nelson’s complaint sought to recover for damage to the property allegedly occurring after September 17,1979, the date that the specific performance decree, subsequently affirmed by the Supreme Court, had originally been entered in the trial court. Smothers answered and, among his other defenses, asserted that Nelson “was not the legal owner on the date on which the alleged damage took place.”

Smothers subsequently moved for and was granted summary judgment. Despite the fact that he was ruling on a motion for summary judgment, the trial court entered an order making findings of fact and conclusions of law. The trial court’s conclusion of law was that “[o]n the dates of the alleged damages to the property, . . ., Smothers had both possession and title to the property and would not be [liable] to Nelson for any damages...” This ultimate conclusion of law that Smothers rather than Nelson had title to the property at the

*113

relevant times was ultimately premised upon the trial court’s findings of fact regarding the actual wording of the judgment of September 17, 1979, entered in the previous specific performance action between the parties. A copy of the judgment in the prior action was not introduced into evidence or filed in the instant case and, accordingly, that judgment does not appear in the record before us.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.