Court of Appeals of North Carolina November 2, 1982, 8118SC1276 (Dixon, Odom & Co. v. Sledge)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-11-1982

HEDRICK, Judge.

Defendants first contend that summary judgment was improperly granted for the plaintiff because a genuine issue of material fact exists as to what constitutes a “former client” under the agreement. Defendants argue the term “former client” is ambiguous and does not describe the intentions of the contracting parties. One interpretation of “former clients” given by the defendants is that one of plaintiff’s clients could change to a third, unrelated accounting firm and later change to defendant Sledge’s firm. This, argues the defendants, was not a situation contemplated by the contracting parties when they entered into the agreement. Yet, a likely occurrence would come about where defendants advised potential clients, who were also former clients of the plaintiff, to use a third firm before moving their business to defendants in order to circumvent the agreement between plaintiff and defendants.

*284

Nonetheless, this court need not entertain all the possible interpretations of “former clients” in order to decide this case. Where the provisions of a contract are plainly set out, the court is not free to disregard them and a party may not contend for a different interpretation on the ground that it does not truly express the intent of the parties.

Taylor v. Gibbs,

268 N.C. 363, 150 S.E. 2d 506 (1966). We find the language of this agreement, made between professional men, who are deemed capable of guarding their own interest and remaining free from compulsion, is clear and unambiguous on its face. This finding obviates defendants’ argument that “former clients” is not what the parties meant at the time of contracting. We note that the agreement contains seven subparagraphs below the provision setting out the obligations concerning “former clients.” Furthermore, plaintiff’s “Exhibit F” shows that defendant Sledge suggested that “fees be paid to cover

present or future clients

who become my client during a ten year period to end January 10, 1987.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.