Court of Appeals of North Carolina May 4, 1982, 8126SC862 (Reidy v. MacAuley)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-05-1982
BECTON, Judge.
Plaintiff states her sole argument thusly: “The Court erred by granting the defendant’s [sic] motion for directed verdict at the close of all the evidence on the grounds that there was ample
*186
record evidence of every element of the plaintiffs claims sufficient to take the case to the jury.” Believing, first, that plaintiff is, at best, an incidental beneficiary under the Contract between the Meyers and defendants and, therefore, not entitled to maintain an action for breach of contract against the defendants; and, second, that the broker’s commission provision inserted into the Contract is unsupported by consideration and, therefore, unenforceable against defendants, we reject plaintiffs argument.
Since
Vogel v. Supply Co.
and
Supply Co. v. Developers, Inc.,
277 N.C. 119, 177 S.E. 2d 273 (1970), our courts have consistently held that one may not maintain an action for breach of contract unless the contract was entered into for his or her direct benefit.
Matternes v. City of Winston-Salem,
286 N.C. 1, 209 S.E. 2d 481 (1974);
Alva v. Cloninger,
51 N.C. App. 602, 277 S.E. 2d 535 (1981);
Howell v. Fisher,
49 N.C. App. 488, 272 S.E. 2d 19 (1980),
disc. rev. denied
302 N.C. 218, 277 S.E. 2d 69 (1981);
Johnson v. Wall,
38 N.C. App. 406, 248 S.E. 2d 571 (1978).
See also
30 A.L.R. 3d Annot. 1395 (1970). The
Vogel
Court expressly adopted the “framework for analysis” of third party beneficiary claims set forth in the American Law Institute’s 1932 Restatement of Contracts, requiring the promisee to either confer a gift on the beneficiary (the beneficiary being designated a “donee-beneficiary”) or act to satisfy a duty owed to the beneficiary (the beneficiary being designated a “creditor-beneficiary”). Under the 1932 Restatement, other beneficiaries were deemed “incidental-beneficiaries” and were not allowed to maintain suits as third party beneficiaries.
See
Restatement of Contracts § 133 (1932).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit